How to design a fair custom map

A beautiful map that favours one player will not get played twice. Fairness does not mean that every player's land has to be identical. It means that no player gets an advantage just from where they spawned.

Start from a known baseline

Official maps give a useful reference. In the game's starting_resources.inc, the default start has 6 forage bushes, a 7-tile primary gold mine, two more gold mines of 4, a 5-tile primary stone mine and a secondary stone mine of 4. Arabia also adds starting sheep, deer and boar. If your start is far below that, players will struggle in the first few minutes. If it is far above, your map plays as a boom map, which may be exactly what you want.

Use real symmetry

Symmetry is the simplest way to make a map fair. The right type depends on the player count:

  • Rotate gives each player the same land, turned around the centre. Use the number of players: Rotate Γ—2 for a duel, Γ—4 for four players.
  • Mirror copies across a line. It works well for two teams facing each other.

Rotation is usually better than mirroring for free-for-all games. With a mirror, players next to the line can have different neighbours from those further away. In the Map Painter, the Symmetry control does this for you as you draw.

Measure distance as well as quantity

Ten gold tiles 40 tiles away are worth much less than seven beside your Town Center. Far resources cost walking time and are harder to defend. When you compare starts, count what each player can reach safely, not the total on their side of the map.

Official scripts control this with distance rules. Black Forest places secondary gold at distance 16, tertiary gold at 22, primary stone at 14 and secondary stone at 20, for example. Every player gets the same rule, even though the map is random.

Check forest and wood access

  • Every player needs a usable woodline close to the start.
  • Check how open each base is. A base with forest on three sides is far easier to defend than one on open ground.
  • Scripts use set_avoid_player_start_areas to keep forests off starts, so you can tune this space.

Give players something to fight over

A fair map does not need to be a calm map. Shared prizes in neutral ground create action. Put them at equal distance from all players:

  • Extra gold in the middle, as Gold Rush does.
  • Relics placed away from the starts.
  • A strong hill position, or a neutral building.

The further an objective is from every base, the more commitment it takes to hold it. This is what gives a map a shape to its games.

Think about team positions

In team games, check flank and pocket positions. A pocket player sits behind allies and can build up safely, while flanks take the first attacks. That is normal in the game, but on a custom map make sure the pocket does not also get the best resources. On painted maps, use the Teams setting so that allies start together.

Water maps need extra care

Look at both fish and shoreline. A player with a narrow bay can be trapped by one strong fleet, while a player on open sea has more room but is exposed. Fish should be at a similar distance for everyone.

Test it properly

  1. Run Check fairness in the Painter, which counts the gold, stone, food and forest each start can reach.
  2. Play a skirmish from each start, or at least from the two that look most different.
  3. Generate random scripts several times, since one lucky result proves very little.
  4. Ask someone else to play it, and watch where they have trouble.
  5. Share it on the Community page and read the ratings.